i

Environmental Law Journal becomes part of Scielo Chile

The publication edited by the Environmental Law Center will be part of an open access collection of Chilean scientific journals in all areas of knowledge.

The Environmental Law Journal, edited by the Environmental Law Center of the Law School of the University of Chile, was admitted to be part of the SciELO - Chile Scientific Electronic Library.

SciELO - Chile is an open access collection of texts from Chilean scientific journals, from all areas of knowledge, which predominantly publish articles resulting from scientific research, and which uses peer review of the manuscripts they receive, which show a growing performance in the indicators of compliance with the indexing criteria.

"We are very pleased with this recognition, which is the result of an effort of continuous improvement of the editorial processes developed by the editorial team, which has resulted in the growing increase in the quality of the articles published over the years," said the director of the Journal, Prof. Valentina Durán Medina, adding "we are grateful for the support of the Faculty, which through its Dean, Prof. Pablo Ruiz-Tagle, and the Journals Program of the Research Department, headed by Prof. Daniel Álvarez, has provided permanent support to the work of the journal."

"Once the collaboration agreement between the Faculty of Law of the University of Chile and the National Agency for Research and Development (ANID) is signed, the full incorporation of the journal to this collection will take place, starting in 2022" explained the editor Jorge Ossandón Rosales.

This good news is in addition to the admission, in 2020, of the Environmental Law Journal to the SCOPUS database.

As a result, in 2022 the Environmental Law Journal will already be indexed in Scopus, Redib, DOAJ and Latindex, in addition to ScIELO, with the support of SISIB and the Journals Program of the Research Department of the Law School of the Universidad of Chile.

It should be noted that Issue 16 of this biannual journal will be published on December 31.

 

Determination of rules and criteria of environmental justice in the enforcement powers of the Superintendency of the Environment

Authors

Abstract

This work proposes that the regulatory design of certain instruments incorporated to the Organic Law of the Superintendency of the Environment allows the application of environmental justice rules and criteria. In order to identify which are the possible applicable environmental justice standards, an analysis of the regulations and administrative practice of the said authority, since its entry into force, is carried out, with special emphasis on inspection programs and subprograms, compliance programs and environmental sanctions. Next, the paper includes an explanation of the development and conclusions of an empirical study on the application of these instruments in certain municipalities that have been classified as “sacrifice zones”. Finally, based on this analysis, various rules and criteria of environmental justice that are applicable to environmental enforcement are identified and proposed.

Keywords:

environmental enforcement, environmental justice, sacrifice zones, Superintendence of the Environment

Author Biographies

Dominique Herve Espejo, Universidad Diego Portales

D. in Law, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso. Associate Professor at the Law School of Universidad Diego Portales, Chile.

Franco Arias Contreras, Universidad Diego Portales

Lawyer, Universidad Diego Portales, and assistant professor of the Environmental Law and Policy Program of the same university.

References

Bermúdez, Jorge (2014). Fundamentos del derecho ambiental. 2.a ed. Valparaíso: Ediciones Universitarias de Valparaíso.

Cannoni, Leslie, Cristóbal Osorio, y Felipe Riesco (2015). «Seguimiento y sanción de los instrumentos de gestión ambiental.». Revista de Derecho Ambiental, 5: 115-151. Disponible en https://bit.ly/43kh1JV.

Esteve, José (2018). «La determinación del riesgo permitido: Referencias constitucionales e instrumentos de decisión». En Dominique Hervé y Sebastián Riestra (editores), Riesgos, derecho y medio ambiente (pp. 15-45). Valparaíso: Ediciones Universitarias de Valparaíso.

Figueroa, Eugenio y Dominique Hervé (2006). «Evaluación del marco institucional y de la gestión ambiental en Chile». Serie En Foco, 97. Disponible en https://bit.ly/3Nbik85.

Galaz-Mandakovic, Damir (2021). «La necroeconomía de la generación de electricidad para la minería: El impacto comunitario del uso del petcoke en Tocopilla (Chile, 2000-2015)». Revista CUHSO, 31 (2): 212-249. DOI: 10.7770/CUHSO-V31N2-ART2155.

Hernández, José (2017). «El problema con las potestades de fiscalización ambiental: ¿Déjà vu?». Revista de Derecho Ambiental, 7: 7-34.

Hervé, Dominique (2015). Justicia ambiental y recursos naturales. Valparaíso: Ediciones Universitarias de Valparaíso.

—. (2018). «¿Fiscalización ambiental exclusiva o concurrente? La respuesta judicial en el caso Los Fiordos». En Anuario de Derecho Público (pp. 343-360). Santiago: Universidad Diego Portales.

Hervé, Dominique y Marie-Claude Plumer (2019). «Instrumentos para una intervención institucional estratégica en la fiscalización, sanción y cumplimiento ambiental: El caso del programa de cumplimiento». Revista de Derecho (Universidad de Concepción), 245: 11-49. Disponible en https://bit.ly/43l3txK.

Hervé, Dominique (2024). «Más allá del cumplimiento: la justicia como un objetivo de la fiscalización y sanción ambiental" en Revista Derecho del Estado (Universidad Externado de Colombia) Nº58, en prensa.

Infante, Paloma (2016). «(In)justicia ambiental en Chile y principales mecanismos para mitigar la inequidad: Planificación territorial y derechos de comunidades vulnerables». Revista de Derecho Ambiental, 6: 143-163. Disponible en https://bit.ly/42mosP9.

Instituto Nacional de Derechos Humanos (INDH)(2014). Informe anual 2014: Situación de los derechos humanos en Chile.

Juskus, Ryan (2023). «Sacrifice zones: A genealogy and analysis of an environmental justice concept». Environmental Humanities, 15 (1): 3-24. Disponible en https://bit.ly/3qvV6k7.

López, Gianni (2006). «Propuesta de una nueva institucionalidad para la fiscalización ambiental de la industria». Serie En Foco, 96.

Lorca, Mauricio y Juan Pablo Silva-Escobar (2020). «Conflictividad y acción colectiva en el Valle del Huasco (1990-2019)». Revista Izquierdas, 49: 4.564-4.583.

Ossandón, Jorge (2015). Incentivos al cumplimiento ambiental. Santiago: Editorial Libromar.

Plumer Bodin, Marie-Claude, Ariel Espinoza y Benjamin Muhr (2018). «El programa de cumplimiento: Desarrollo actual e importancia del instrumento para la solución de conflictos ambientales». Revista de Derecho Ambiental, 9: 209-236. Disponible en https://bit.ly/3Nd1BBo.

Retamal, Alejandro, Pedro Villasana, Felipe Vergara, Juan Mansilla y Germán Moreno (2021). «Zonas de sacrificio en Chile, criterios y condiciones de posibilidad: El caso del Seno del Reloncaví». Revista Notas Históricas y Geográficas, 26: 95-143.

Rubin, Douglas (2010). «How supplemental environmental projects can and should be used to advance environmental justice». University of Maryland Law Journal of Race, Religion, Gender and Class, 10 (1): 179-198.

Soto, Pablo (2016). «Determinación de sanciones administrativas: Disuasión óptima y confinamiento de la discrecionalidad del regulador ambiental». En Anuario de Derecho Público (pp. 374-407). Santiago: Universidad Diego Portales.